Stone Soup is an ongoing quarantine feature in which I come up with a recipe that uses the impossible thing in your cupboard, without making you go to the store or wasting any of your ingredients. Last time, we caramelized some brassicas.
A personal note before we dive in: thank you all so much for your emails and comments and especially for sharing the results of your kitchen experiments on social media! I can’t adequately describe how much it lifts my spirits every time I see that one of you has tried something new in the kitchen, taken a risk, or performed a series of risky substitutions. Please keep being creative and amazing, and please always tag me @gaileyfrey when you feel like showing off. It’s my favorite thing.
Today’s Stone Soup is going to be a little bit different from the others. Wesley says:
My wife and I made Jerk Chicken with a side of peas and rice - which came out quite good! However, as I was purchasing ingredients at our local asian market, I ended up with a plethora of peppers (scotch bonnet and jalapeno) - please see attached picture.
We are looking for suggestions as to how to use up these tasty (but rather spicy) peppers. We have a well-stocked kitchen for most staples and proteins so can make many things - we just need inspiration.

Okay, gang, here’s the thing. I’ve been sitting on this one for ages, because I’m fully stumped. I know how to use, like, one or two peppers at a time in a recipe. I kind of know how to pickle peppers, but pickling scotch bonnets requires a very well-ventilated kitchen and I don’t want anyone filling their home with aerosolized pepper spray by accident. Air-drying is okay, but I’m not sure how well jalapenos take to it, given how fleshy they are — I’d probably wind up turning them into powder for seasoning, which feels like a dull solution for such a gorgeous pepper.
So I’m asking for your help. The comments are open. Who has tips for how Wesley can use up or safely preserve all these peppers?
If you have a pantry dilemma, send it to stonesoup.substack@gmail.com. If you’re enjoying this feature, leave a comment below or share it on social media. Stay safe, stay healthy, and for pete’s sake, stay home.
Subscribe to Stone Soup
Subscribe to the newsletter and unlock access to member-only content.